Interesting reads on digital marketing and other topics

Online reviews play a huge role in how customers choose businesses—and how businesses rank in local search. But what happens when a review is clearly spam, fake, or malicious?

Many business owners assume that once a spam review is reported, Google will automatically remove it. In reality, Google’s review moderation process is far more conservative—and often frustratingly slow.

This post breaks down how Google actually handles reported spam reviews, why obvious fakes often remain visible, and what you can realistically do about it.

1. Google Relies Heavily on Automation, Not Humans

Google receives millions of reviews every day across Google Maps and Google Business Profiles. Because of this scale, most review moderation is handled by automated systems, not human reviewers.

When a review is reported, Google’s systems look for signals such as:

• Repeated or copy-paste content
  
  

• Suspicious reviewer behavior (mass posting, new accounts)
  
  

• Policy-violating language (hate speech, threats, profanity)
  
  

• Clear conflicts of interest
  
  

If the system doesn’t detect strong violations, the review may stay up—even if it feels obviously fake to the business owner.

Key takeaway: Reporting a review does not guarantee a human review.

2. “Looks Fake” Is Not Enough Under Google’s Policies

Google only removes reviews that violate its Reviews Policy, not reviews that are:

• Unfair
  
  

• Incorrect
  
  

• One-sided
  
  

• Written by someone who misunderstood your business
  
  

For example, these often do not qualify for removal:

• A customer who never booked but “called once”
  
  

• A competitor pretending to be a customer (unless provable)
  
  

• A vague 1-star review with no details
  
  

• A review based on policy disagreements (pricing, hours, rules)
  
  

From Google’s perspective, these still count as “opinions.”

3. The Review Reporting Tool Is Conservative by Design

When you flag a review in Google Business Profile or Maps:

1. The review is scanned by automated systems
   
   

2. It’s checked against known spam patterns
   
   

3. Only high-confidence violations are removed
   
   

This is why many spam reviews sit in a “Pending” state for weeks—or forever.

Google intentionally sets a high bar because:

• Over-removal could censor legitimate customers
  
  

• Businesses might abuse the system to delete negative feedback
  
  

• Automation must err on the side of leaving content up
  
  

4. When Google Is More Likely to Remove a Review

Spam reviews are more likely to be removed if they involve:

• Reviews from accounts with no other activity
  
  

• Identical wording across multiple businesses
  
  

• Reviews posted from impossible locations
  
  

• Explicit advertising, links, or phone numbers
  
  

• Reviews naming the wrong business entirely
  
  

• Clearly abusive or threatening language
  
  

Even then, removal is not guaranteed.

5. Why Escalations Sometimes Work (But Not Always)

In some cases, submitting reviews through Google’s Review Removal Tool or escalating via official support channels can help—especially if:

• Multiple reviews show the same spam pattern
  
  

• The review clearly references another business
  
  

• The reviewer admits they were never a customer
  
  

That said, Google rarely explains why a review was or wasn’t removed, which adds to the confusion.

6. What Businesses Should Do Instead of Waiting

Because Google is slow and selective, the most effective strategy is defensive reputation management, not just review removal.

Best practices include:

• Responding calmly and professionally to suspicious reviews
  
  

• Encouraging real customers to leave honest feedback
  
  

• Maintaining consistent business information (NAP consistency)
  
  

• Monitoring reviews regularly for patterns, not one-offs
  
  

Ironically, a well-written response to a spam review often builds more trust with potential customers than deleting it ever would.

Final Thoughts

Google’s approach to spam reviews prioritizes scale, automation, and free expression—not business convenience. While this can feel unfair, understanding how the system works helps set realistic expectations and smarter strategies.

Spam reviews are annoying.
But silence, overreaction, or waiting indefinitely for Google to fix them is usually worse.

When it comes to building trust online, nothing is more valuable than authentic customer feedback. Instead of relying on fake or manipulated reviews, businesses can strengthen their reputation by focusing on real engagement and genuine experiences.

Encourage Happy Customers to Share Their Experience
One of the most effective ways to generate positive reviews is simply to ask. After a great interaction, kindly invite customers to leave feedback on your Google Business Profile. Whether it’s a quick in-person reminder or a follow-up message, small prompts can make a big difference.

Provide Value Without Incentives
While offering rewards for reviews is against Google’s policies, you can still create an environment that naturally encourages feedback. Sharing helpful tips, updates, or educational content keeps customers engaged and increases the likelihood that they’ll leave a review on their own.

Turn Negative Feedback Into Growth
Every business receives less-than-perfect reviews from time to time. Responding politely, addressing concerns, and showing a willingness to improve demonstrates professionalism and care. This transparency helps build long-term trust and reassures potential customers that their experience matters.

By focusing on honest interactions and meaningful communication, businesses can build a strong, trustworthy online presence — one genuine review at a time.

When people search for local businesses today, they don’t just look for addresses or hours—they look for reviews. In fact, studies show that nearly 9 out of 10 customers trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations. For small businesses, reviews are no longer optional; they’re a critical driver of visibility, reputation, and ultimately, revenue.

1. Reviews Influence Where You Show Up on Google

Google uses reviews as a ranking signal in local search. A business with frequent, positive reviews is more likely to appear in the Local Pack (the top three listings in Google Maps). This means more people will see your business first, before scrolling down to competitors.

Example: A local café with 200 reviews and a 4.6-star rating will usually outrank a café with 20 reviews and a 3.8-star rating—even if both are in the same area.

2. Reviews Build Trust Before Customers Visit

Your reputation is often decided before a customer ever calls or walks through your door. Positive reviews signal credibility, professionalism, and quality. Negative reviews, if left unmanaged, can drive potential customers away.

Pro Tip: Responding to reviews—positive or negative—shows customers that you care and can even turn a bad experience into a trust-building moment.

3. Reviews Drive Conversions, Not Just Clicks

Visibility is important, but trust drives action. A strong review profile encourages people to call, book an appointment, or visit your location. In competitive industries—like restaurants, law offices, or dental practices—reviews can be the deciding factor between you and another business.

4. Reviews Provide Valuable Feedback

Beyond marketing value, reviews give you insights into what customers love and what can be improved. Whether it’s service speed, product quality, or atmosphere, these comments highlight opportunities to grow and refine your customer experience.

5. A Reputation Strategy Is Essential

Collecting and managing reviews doesn’t happen by accident. Successful local businesses use strategies like:

• Asking happy customers for reviews at the right time
  
  

• Making it easy to leave a review (via a link or QR code)
  
  

• Responding quickly and professionally
  
  

• Monitoring reviews regularly for trends
  
  

Final Thoughts

Your business’s reputation is one of its most powerful marketing assets. Reviews don’t just reflect your past—they shape your future by influencing who finds you and who chooses you.

At Vanguard Visibility, we help small businesses strengthen their online reputation so they can show up higher in search, earn trust faster, and attract more customers.